How to Build & Read an SPX Broken-Wing Butterfly Risk Graph: Uneven Wings, One Breakeven & Max Loss

What This Tutorial Covers

A broken-wing butterfly is a butterfly whose two wings are different widths. This tutorial builds an SPX put broken-wing butterfly from scratch in the MyATMM Risk Profile tool, on a demo account, and reads how the uneven wings change its shape on the chart: a flat side, a peak, a single breakeven and the max loss. Then the trade’s row on the Strategy Summary page picks up its max risk from the saved profile.

It is a demonstration of a tracking tool. Nothing here is investment advice; it shows how a position gets drawn and tracked, not what to trade. For a butterfly with equal wings, see an iron butterfly compared with an iron condor on one SPX expiration.

Step 1: Create a Profile for One Expiration

The plus button starts a new profile. The demo names it Put Broken Wing Butterfly and picks November 25 as the target expiration, which the dialog marks as settling in the afternoon. Create Profile saves it, and the empty profile waits for its first spread.

Step 2: Add Three Legs and Flip Them to Puts

Add First Spread opens the inline editor with a two-leg call vertical. Add Leg makes three legs, and the editor sets the butterfly ratio on its own: buy one, sell two, buy one. The type button flips a leg from call to put, one click per leg, and the spread label reads Butterfly.

Step 3: Unlink the Strikes and Break a Wing

The chain icon unlinks the strikes so each one can be typed on its own. The demo uses these strikes:

  • Buy one 7200 put
  • Sell two 7300 puts
  • Buy one 7350 put

The lower wing, 7200 to 7300, is 100 points wide. The upper wing, 7300 to 7350, is only 50. That is the broken wing. The label still says Butterfly, because the editor names the shape by its legs: three puts in a one-two-one ratio.

MyATMM Risk Profile legs editor showing an SPX put broken-wing butterfly: buy one 7200 put, sell two 7300 puts, buy one 7350 put, with the spread label reading Butterfly

Three puts at 7200, 7300 and 7350 in a one-two-one ratio. The price is still following live quotes here, before the lock.

Step 4: Lock the Price and Enter It as a Credit

While the editor is open, the price field tracks live quotes. The lock switches it to manual entry. The demo enters 5.80 with a minus sign in front, which records it as a credit, cash received for the whole structure, and the label beside it reads Credit. The check mark saves the spread, and the Net credit chip shows $580 on one contract.

Step 5: Read the Expiration Line

The green line is the position at expiration. Reading it from right to left:

  • Above 7350, all three puts expire worthless and the line sits flat at +$580, the credit
  • Moving left, it climbs to a peak at the short strike, 7300: $5,580, the 50-point upper wing ($5,000) plus the credit
  • Left of the peak, it falls back through zero at the single breakeven, 7244.20
  • Below 7200 it flattens at −$4,420, the same number as the Max risk chip

The breakeven is the short strike minus the upper wing minus the credit: 7300 − 50 − 5.80 = 7244.20. Max risk is the extra width of the lower wing, 50 points or $5,000, less the $580 credit.

MyATMM Risk Profile chart of an SPX put broken-wing butterfly showing the flat expiration line at plus $580 above 7350, the peak at 7300, the single breakeven at 7244.20 and the $4,420 max loss below 7200, with the net credit and max risk chips above the three legs

The flat +$580 side above 7350, the peak at 7300, the single breakeven at 7244.20 and the $4,420 max loss below 7200, with the Net credit and Max risk chips above the legs.

Step 6: Compare It With Equal Wings

With equal wings, the expiration line would drop below zero on both sides, for two breakevens. Here the lower wing is wider, so its long put costs less, the whole structure opens for a credit, and the right side of the expiration line never goes negative. Another way to see it: the 7200/7300 pair on its own is a 100-point put credit spread, with a 50-point put debit spread, 7300/7350, stacked on top.

The Today line tells a different story: the pink line is the model’s estimate at today’s date, eight days out. It is still nearly straight, and in the demo it sits below zero across the whole chart. The peak and the corners only take shape close to expiration, so the flat side is an expiration-day reading, not where the position stands along the way.

Step 7: Track the Trade on Strategy Summary

Strategy Summary, under Tools, tracks the trade itself. On the Upcoming Expirations tab, November 25 has one row: one transaction, three legs and $575.12 booked so far, the credit net of fees. Max Risk is $4,420, and the check mark beside it says where that number comes from: the saved Put Broken Wing Butterfly profile. ROI divides the P&L so far by that max risk, and the icon in the Risk Profile column jumps straight back to the chart.

MyATMM Strategy Summary Upcoming Expirations tab showing one Nov 25 2026 SPX row with one transaction, three legs, $575.12 P&L so far, a $4,420 max risk read from the saved profile and a 13.0% ROI

Strategy Summary, Upcoming Expirations: the Nov 25 row with the $4,420 max risk from the saved profile and the jump back to the Risk Profile on the right.

Uneven Wings, One Breakeven

That is a put broken-wing butterfly in MyATMM: one wing wider than the other, a single breakeven, and a flat side that keeps the credit at expiration. The same Risk Profile tool draws a four-leg SPX iron condor with two breakevens. If you are comparing tools for multi-leg index positions, see the best iron condor tracker apps for 2026.

Risk Disclaimer

Options trading involves risk and is not suitable for all investors. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This content is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. The positions shown are demo data. Always consult with a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.

Related Reading

Start Tracking Your Options Positions Accurately

MyATMM provides purpose-built cost basis tracking for option sellers, with the flexibility to track covered calls, cash-secured puts, and wheel strategy positions.

Track up to 3 tickers completely free forever. No credit card required.

Create Your Free Account Today

Built for covered calls, cash-secured puts, and the wheel strategy

Original Content by MyATMM Research Team | Published: November 18, 2026 | Educational Use Only