Robinhood made options trading approachable for a whole generation of retail traders. Zero commissions, a clean mobile app, and a one-tap order ticket pulled millions of people into selling cash-secured puts and covered calls for the first time. If that's how you got started running the wheel, you're in good company.
But once you've been at it for a few months, a different problem shows up. Robinhood is built to help you place a trade, not to help you track a position across its whole life. The moment your wheel spans a put, an assignment, and a few rounds of covered calls, the app stops telling you the one number you actually trade on: your real, premium-adjusted cost basis. This is a look at exactly where Robinhood's tracking runs out and what the best options tracker for Robinhood users does instead.
Short answer: it tracks cost basis for tax reporting, but not the working cost basis an option seller needs to make decisions. Those are two different numbers, and the gap between them is where wheel traders get tripped up.
Here's the mechanics. When you sell a cash-secured put on Robinhood and get assigned, the app records your new shares at the strike price. The premium you collected selling that put? It's logged as its own separate, closed options trade with its own profit-and-loss line. Your share position knows nothing about it.
So say you sell a $20 put on a stock, collect $0.80 in premium, and get assigned. Your true cost basis is $19.20 a share — you paid $20 but kept $0.80. Robinhood shows your shares at $20.00. The $0.80 lives somewhere else in your history.
Now stack that across an entire wheel. A single position might run for months: the put, the assignment, three or four rounds of covered calls, maybe a dividend, and eventually shares called away. Each covered call you sell drops your real basis a little more. Robinhood treats every one of those as a separate, unrelated event. There's no thread connecting the put you sold in February to the calls you're selling in May. You're left to reconstruct the running total in your head or in a spreadsheet.
This isn't a hit piece. Robinhood is genuinely good at a lot, and it's worth being clear about what you'd be keeping:
The thing to notice is that every one of those strengths is about a single trade or a single tax year. None of them is about the lifecycle of a wheel position — the put, the shares, the calls, and the running basis treated as one connected thing. That's the gap, and it's not a bug. It's just not what Robinhood was built to do.
Yes — and this is the natural first instinct, so it's worth being honest about how far it gets you. Robinhood lets you download account statements and a CSV of your activity from both the app and the web dashboard. You can pull your whole options history out.
The catch is what comes back. The export is a flat list of individual fills — sell-to-open here, an assignment there, a buy-to-close somewhere else — with no relationship between them. Reassembling that into "this is my INTC wheel and here's where my cost basis stands" is on you. You're back to building formulas in Excel or Google Sheets, and every new trade means going back in and updating the sheet. That works right up until the week you forget, and then your numbers are stale and you don't notice until you've already made a trade against bad data. We've written before about when covered call tracking spreadsheets break down — the failure mode is almost always a missed entry, not a broken formula.
So the export is real, but it's a starting point, not a finish line. The question becomes: what reads that data and turns it into something you can actually trade on?
Whatever tool you pick, it has to do the things Robinhood structurally can't. The short list:
That last point is the one that quietly filters out most tools. General trade journals and broker dashboards are built around the buy-low-sell-high model. Selling premium to lower your basis over time is a different shape entirely, and tools that weren't designed for it end up making you do the adjustment math by hand anyway. If you want the full checklist, we broke it down in what to look for in options trading journal software.
This is the exact gap MyATMM was built to fill — by an option seller who hit these same walls and got tired of reconstructing cost basis in a spreadsheet. It doesn't replace Robinhood; you keep trading there. It sits alongside your broker as the tracking and analytics layer the app doesn't provide for wheel-specific workflows.
There are two paths, and most people mix them:
AI screenshot import. Fill an order on Robinhood, screenshot the confirmation, and upload it. The AI reads the screenshot and pulls out the ticker, strike, expiration, premium, quantity, and date, then drops it into an entry form for you to confirm. Roughly fifteen seconds per trade, no typing. It works with Robinhood order confirmations and position screens — we put it through its paces in our Fidelity and Robinhood screenshot import test.
CSV import. Already exported your activity? You can bring the file straight in. The full walkthrough lives in importing Robinhood CSV transactions with AI, including how duplicate detection keeps you from double-counting fills.
Once your trades are in, you get the numbers the app can't surface:
A quick side-by-side of what each tool is actually for:
| Capability | Robinhood | Spreadsheet | MyATMM |
|---|---|---|---|
| Place trades | Yes | No | No |
| Premium-adjusted cost basis | No | Manual | Automatic |
| Connected wheel lifecycle | No | Manual | Yes |
| Cumulative premium per ticker | No | Manual | Yes |
| Import from Robinhood | — | Manual | CSV + AI screenshot |
| Built for option sellers | Partial | DIY | Yes |
Robinhood and MyATMM aren't competitors — they do different jobs. Robinhood is your speedometer: what's happening right now. A purpose-built tracker is your trip log: where every position stands after accounting for everything you've collected along the way.
If you're a Robinhood trader keeping a spreadsheet for your wheel positions — or trying to hold the running basis in your head — it's worth trying a tool built for exactly this. Pull up one of your active wheels, import it, and see whether the premium-adjusted basis matches your own math. If it does, you've got an honest number to trade on. If you've been guessing, you'll see by how much.
You can run that test free at myatmm.com — three tickers, no credit card, no time limit. If the wheel is your strategy and Robinhood is your broker, that's the gap this fills.
Options trading involves risk and is not suitable for all investors. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This content is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Always consult with a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions. MyATMM is a tracking tool and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Robinhood.
Further reading: What to look for in options trading journal software.
MyATMM tracks your Robinhood covered calls, cash-secured puts, and wheel positions as connected lifecycles — with premium-adjusted cost basis that's right every time you go to sell the next call.
Track up to 3 tickers completely free forever. No credit card required.
Create Your Free AccountBuilt for covered calls, cash-secured puts, and the wheel strategy