Most "options trackers" on the market were designed for option buyers — people scanning for directional plays, paying premium up front, and trying to time exits. The math is simple: you bought a contract at X, you closed it at Y, here's your P/L. A spreadsheet handles that fine.
Selling options is a different beast. You're collecting premium up front, taking on a contingent obligation, sometimes getting assigned, sometimes rolling, sometimes piling premium onto the same underlying for months. The question isn't "did this trade win?" — it's "what is this position actually doing for me across the full cycle?"
That mismatch is why a generic options tracker leaves option sellers frustrated. The features that matter to a buyer don't matter to you, and the things you actually need are usually missing.
Before you compare specific tools, here's the checklist of capabilities that actually matter when your strategy is selling premium for income.
Total premium collected on a given ticker, across every contract you've sold against it, in one place. Not a list of trades you have to manually add up — a running total per underlying.
Every cash-secured put ties up capital. Every credit spread ties up margin. Your tracker should show what you have committed at any moment, not just open contracts.
Sold a put, got assigned, started selling covered calls — that's one position playing out, not three unrelated trades. The tracker should connect them, with cost basis adjusting at every step.
Every premium credit, every dividend, every covered call — they should all reduce your effective cost basis automatically. That number drives every strike-selection decision you make. If your tracker shows you the brokerage cost basis instead of your real adjusted cost basis, it's not built for sellers.
Closing a put for $0.30 and opening a new one for $0.80 isn't two trades — it's a roll, and the tracker should treat it that way. Otherwise you'll either double-count or lose the connection.
If you sell CSPs, covered calls, credit spreads, and the occasional iron condor, the tracker shouldn't force you into one workflow. Spreads have their own collateral and max-loss math; the tool needs to handle it.
Buyers measure "trades won." Sellers measure income generated, premium collected per dollar of capital deployed, and how consistent that income is month over month. Performance reporting should reflect that lens.
Tracking is only half the workflow. The other half is finding good candidates — high IV rank, weekly options, manageable size. A platform that includes both keeps you in one tool.
The tools available to option sellers in 2026 fall into roughly four buckets. Each has tradeoffs.
Schwab, Fidelity, Tastytrade, Robinhood, Webull — every broker has a positions screen and a P/L view. Tastytrade is the most option-seller-friendly, but even there, the cost basis math doesn't reflect the way an option seller actually thinks about a position. Brokerage tools show you data, not a workflow.
Sharesight, Snowball Analytics, Yahoo Finance, Stock Analysis. Solid for buy-and-hold investors who collect dividends, weak on options. If you sell occasional covered calls on top of a long-term portfolio, they may work; if options income is your primary strategy, the gaps will frustrate you.
Still the most common option-seller tracking system, and the reason most sellers eventually look for a tool. Spreadsheets work great until they don't — until your formulas break on a roll, until you forget to log an expiration, until the cost basis drift makes you stop trusting your own data. We covered this in detail in our breakdown of moving from a wheel strategy spreadsheet to a dedicated tracker and the inflection points where covered call spreadsheets break down.
This is the smallest bucket but the most useful one. Tools designed specifically around the seller workflow — with assignment-aware lifecycle tracking, automatic cost basis adjustments, and integrated income reporting. MyATMM sits here. So do a handful of newer tools focused on the wheel strategy specifically, which we've compared in our wheel strategy tracker breakdown.
If you're new to selling options, your path looks something like this: you start with the brokerage's positions screen, realize it doesn't show what you need, and build a spreadsheet. The spreadsheet works for a while, then breaks somewhere — usually around the third or fourth roll, or when you start running multiple strategies on multiple tickers at once.
That breaking point is when most sellers go looking for a real options portfolio tracker. The question becomes: what features actually matter, and which tools have them?
The honest answer: it depends on what you sell. CSP-and-CC sellers running the wheel have different needs than credit-spread traders. Below is a quick guide.
You need cost basis that updates automatically across the full cycle — premium, assignment, dividends, covered call premium, called-away P/L. Lifecycle awareness is the killer feature. Wheel-strategy-focused trackers handle this best.
Collateral math gets complicated — each spread ties up max-loss capital, not full strike value. You need a tracker that understands defined-risk math and shows you margin used per spread. Most option-seller tools do this, but you'll want to verify on the specific strategies you trade.
You're looking for a multi-strategy tracker that handles the wheel and spreads and rolls dividend income into the same per-ticker view. This is the broadest case and the hardest to find well. Tastytrade gets you part of the way; a tracker with full dividend integration finishes the job.
Start with whatever tool has a meaningful free tier so you can run a real position through it before committing. MyATMM offers three tickers free with no credit card, which is enough to test a complete wheel cycle and see whether the workflow fits how you trade.
Since this is our blog, here's the angle we built around — not because every seller will love it, but because it tells you what we think matters.
If your current options portfolio tracker doesn't tell you what each ticker has actually paid you across premium, dividends, and the full assignment cycle, your data isn't telling you the truth about your strategy. You're either underestimating your income or guessing at your real cost basis — neither of which makes for better strike selection.
Pick a tool with a real free tier. Run one full cycle on your most-traded ticker — sell a put, take it through assignment if it happens, sell calls against the shares, roll once. At the end, ask: does the cost basis the tracker shows match what I'd compute by hand? If yes, it's built for sellers. If no, the tracker is for buyers and you're using the wrong tool.
You can run that test free at myatmm.com. Three tickers, no credit card, no time limit.
Options trading involves risk and is not suitable for all investors. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This content is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Always consult with a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.
MyATMM is purpose-built for option sellers — covered calls, cash-secured puts, credit spreads, and the full wheel lifecycle, with cost basis that adjusts automatically.
Track up to 3 tickers completely free forever. No credit card required.
Create Your Free Account TodayBuilt for option sellers — not buyers