Most cash-secured put trackers were built around one workflow: sell put, collect premium, log it. That's fine if every CSP you sell expires worthless. But if you sell puts on dividend-paying stocks — and a lot of income-focused traders do — your real income story has two streams: option premium and dividends on assigned shares. A tracker that only sees premium is showing you half the picture.
Generic portfolio apps usually have a "dividends" section and an "options" section that don't talk to each other. You end up with two reports and no way to see how much a single ticker has actually paid you across both. If you're running the wheel on a dividend stock, that disconnect is the whole problem.
Tacking a dividend total onto a portfolio screen isn't the same thing as integrating dividends into your CSP workflow. The features that actually matter:
Here's the workflow that exposes most trackers as not-quite-built-for-this:
You sell a 30-delta put on a dividend stock — say PEP, KO, JNJ, or MCD — and collect premium. Easy enough. Most trackers handle this.
Stock dips, your put gets assigned, and you now own 100 shares at the strike price. Your effective cost basis is the strike minus the premium you collected. A weak tracker resets your cost basis to the strike and forgets the premium ever happened. A good one carries that premium credit forward.
You hold the shares through the ex-dividend date and the next payout hits your account. Now your cost basis should drop again — by the dividend amount per share. Most options-focused trackers either don't track dividends at all, or track them in a separate report that doesn't touch your cost basis math.
You start selling calls against the assigned shares. Premium from those calls also reduces your cost basis. Now your effective cost basis reflects the original CSP premium + every dividend + every covered call premium. That's the number that should drive your strike selection on the next call.
The stock rallies, your call gets assigned, and the shares are gone. Your realized P/L should reflect the strike sold at, minus your fully-adjusted cost basis. If your tracker forgot the dividends or the original CSP premium along the way, your reported P/L is wrong.
The market for option-seller tools has gotten busier, but very few have first-class dividend integration. Here's the honest landscape.
Most brokers (Schwab, Fidelity, Robinhood, Webull) show option premium and dividends as separate line items on separate screens. None of them roll the two together into a per-ticker income picture, and almost none of them adjust your cost basis for collected premium the way an option seller actually thinks about it.
Tools like Sharesight and Snowball Analytics handle dividends well but treat options as either an afterthought or a manual entry exercise. If your strategy is "buy and hold dividend stocks, occasionally sell a CC," they may work. If you're running CSPs as the primary entry mechanism, the options side will feel bolted on.
Trackers built purely around the options side — performance journals, strategy analyzers — typically ignore dividends entirely. Useful for backtesting trade entries, less useful for understanding income on a wheel position.
This is the slice of the market most likely to handle both. MyATMM falls here — it was built specifically for option sellers running the wheel on dividend-paying stocks, so premium and dividends both flow into the same per-ticker cost basis. For a wider comparison, our breakdown of the best wheel strategy trackers compared for 2025 covers the other contenders.
Since this is our blog, here's how we approach it — not because we're the only option, but because it's the workflow we built around.
If you're selling cash-secured puts on dividend stocks and your current tool hides one half of your income, you don't need a bigger spreadsheet — you need a tracker that treats premium and dividends as the same income story per ticker.
Start by listing the three or four tickers you trade most. Log a full lifecycle on one of them — CSP, assignment, dividend, covered call, called-away — in whatever tool you're considering. If the cost basis at the end is the number you'd compute by hand, the tracker passes. If it's missing premium or ignoring the dividend, keep looking.
You can run that test on MyATMM for free — three tickers, no credit card. If it clicks, scale up. If it doesn't, you've learned something about what you actually need from a CSP-and-dividend tracker, which makes the next tool easier to evaluate.
Options trading involves risk and is not suitable for all investors. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This content is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Always consult with a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.
MyATMM rolls every option premium and dividend into a single per-ticker income view, with cost basis that adjusts automatically as you trade.
Track up to 3 tickers completely free forever. No credit card required.
Create Your Free Account TodayBuilt for cash-secured puts, covered calls, and dividend-paying stocks